From the files of the Rochester Historical Society: 1974 pre-Thanksgiving service at First Congregational

Nov 23, 2020
The writer of this piece, Connie Eshbach, is the vice president of the Rochester Historical Society. This is part of a series of Rochester history briefs.
 
As we celebrate a Thanksgiving unlike any in most of our lifetimes, we can take a break from 2020 and go back in time to 1974.
 
That year, Rochester's First Congregational Church had a special pre-Thanksgiving service. The service, a pageant portraying the first Thanksgiving between the Pilgrims and their Wampanoag neighbors, was planned by the church's minister, Rev. Edward White. Sadly, Rev. White passed away on Nov. 17 before the service. However, the church continued on with the program.
 
Many members of the congregation, both young and old, dressed either as Pilgrims or Wampanoags. Children from the Church School presented canned and dry goods to be given out to needy families. The man at the altar who spoke on that day (and who eulogized Rev. White) was Chief Setting Sun. In full tribal costume, he spoke about Rev. White, a modest man, but one who was able to relate to people and their problems. His death had Chief Setting Sun giving himself a new mission to correct the image that many had of all Native Americans. The rest of the pastor's worship service was carried out by the Board of Deacons for about 350 congregants.
 
As we all know, 46 years have changed many of our views of the first Thanksgiving, but reading about this romanticized version of the actual history and even with the sadness of White's death, we get a brief respite from all the worries and disappointments of our 2020  holiday.